I Thought Arguing About Holiday Plans Meant Our Relationship Was Failing

Nov,10,2026

Trust Therapeutics Clinical Team
100% Online across MA, FL & NY
A reflective story about learning that disagreeing over holiday plans can be normal, and that repair is what counts.

Illustrative story. This is a composite written for educational purposes, not a real client account. 

The argument started over where to spend Thanksgiving. Within minutes it felt much bigger than logistics. I lay awake that night wondering if fighting about this meant we were falling apart. 

The Story I Was Telling Myself 

I had absorbed the idea that couples who really love each other do not argue. So every disagreement felt like proof that something was broken. 

What Changed 

The next morning my partner said, “I don’t like how that went. Can we try again?” We each shared what the day meant to us, and the plans mattered less than I thought. 

What I Took From It 

  • Conflict is not the same as failure 
  • Respectful disagreement can build understanding 
  • Repair after a fight matters more than avoiding the fight 

If you have been afraid that arguing means your relationship is failing, you may be putting too much weight on the argument and too little on the repair. 

Try this today: After your next disagreement, say one sentence of repair, like “I care about us, and I want to understand you better.” 

When Arguments Feel Different 

If conflict leaves you afraid, or the same fight repeats without resolution, extra support can help. 

Not sure whether your arguments are normal or a sign you need extra help? Trust Therapeutics therapists can help you sort that out together. Contact us to set up a first session. 

100% Virtual Telehealth Across MA, FL & NY

Take the First Step Toward Better Wellbeing

Therapy doesn’t have to feel intimidating. Meet with a licensed therapist online from the comfort and privacy of your home across Massachusetts, Florida, or New York. We accept most major health insurance plans.

✓ 100% Virtual & HIPAA Video
✓ In-Network: BCBS, Aetna & more
✓ Evening & Weekend Online Slots

Prefer to talk first? Call or text our care team at (866) 439-6161